Why use Nuclear Power?


Several major reasons that people working in the field still remain optimistic about nuclear power are:

Energy Production Rates

Uranium-235 is the isotope of uranium that is used in nuclear reactors. Uranium-235 can produce 3.7 million times as much energy as the same amount of coal. As an example, 7 trucks, each carrying 6 cases of 2-12 foot high fuel assemblies, can fuel a 1000 Megawatt-electrical (MWe) reactor for 1.5 years. During this period, ~ 2 metric tons of Uranium-235 (of the 100 metric tons of fuel - uranium dioxide) would be consumed. To operate a coal plant of the same output would require 1 train of 89-100 ton coal cars each EVERY day. Over 350,000 tons of ash would be produced AND over 4 million tons of carbon dioxide, carbon monoxide, nitrogen oxides and sulfur oxides would be released to the environment.

Typical Container with 2 Fuel Assemblies

Energy Production Costs

The best example of cost comparison is shown by this graph provided by the Nuclear Energy Institute that compares average nuclear and coal production costs over recent years. Nuclear fuel costs are considerably less than coal. However, various capital, operating and maintenance costs for coal may be lower than nuclear. Thus, the 2 costs are comparable.

Courtesy NEI

The various components of energy generation account for the following:

Typically, the plant capital expenses are depreciated over 30 to 40 years. Modifications are depreciated over the remaining life of the plant (usually taken as the end of the current license). The operating and maintenance costs and US DOE and US NRC charges are accounted for as an annual expense. Fuel costs are usually treated separately as a capital expense depreciated over a number of years.

Related pages and figures provided on the site are:

Base Materials Abundant

Uranium ore is used as the raw material to make the uranium fuel. Primary source countries are - United States, South Africa, Australia, Canada, Nigeria - with resources between 270 and 2400 thousand tons each. Other countries having uranium mineral resources with estimated resources of between 36 and 124 thousand tons each are - France, Argentina, India, Algeria, Gabon, Brazil. [R.A. Knief, Nuclear Energy Technology, Hemisphere, 1981]. Since the end of the Cold War, a number of former Soviet Bloc countries as Russia, Kazakhstan, and Uzbekistan have entered the world market as suppliers.

Related figures from the Energy Information Administration's 1998 Uranium Industry Annual Report are:

The uranium ore must go through several steps before it can be placed in a reactor:

Plutonium Byproduct of Reactor Operation

95 to 97% of the fuel in the reactor is uranium-238. Some of this uranium transforms into Plutonium-239 and Plutonium-241 - usually about 1000 kg form after a year of operation. At the end of the cycle (a year to 2 years, typically), very little uranium-235 is left and about 30% of the power produced by the reactor comes from the plutonium.

To some, the plutonium is viewed negatively as the stuff bombs can be made from. To others, plutonium is a resource we need to make use of. Based on DOE projections of fuel assemblies that will be discharged as spent fuel through the year 2030, there would be enough plutonium present in the U.S. spent fuel assemblies to operate 20 reactors for 40 years each. Plutonium-239 decays very slowly (half life is 24,110 years). Thus, this is a resource if the reprocessing option is selected in the future. It should also be pointed out that some of the plutonium byproducts formed during the reactor operation, e.g. Pu-240, do reduce the effectiveness of plutonium as a bomb material by forcing more specialized separation of the Pu-239 isotope.

Countries that have civilian reprocessing facilities (operational or under construction) capable of separating plutonium are - France, India, Japan, United Kingdom, Russia as shown by the Nuclear Control Institute figure below.

Courtesy NCI

Low Quantities of Waste

The fuel assemblies remain in the reactor for 3 to 5 years. The waste, in the form of the radioactive fission products, remains inside the fuel. As noted above about 2000 kg are converted to waste after 1.5 years of operation. Currently, the fuel assemblies remain in cooling pools for about 10 to 15 years. After that time, they are being transferred to special casks for storage where air can be used to cooling. The reduction in radioactivity and thermal levels for the spent fuel are illustrated by the US DOE figures below.

To extract the waste and plutonium from the fuel can result in the generation of liquid wastes since currently nitric acid is used to breakdown the cladding material and the ceramic into solution. The liquid and spent fuel wastes are very radioactive initially. However, these levels also drop as shown in the above figures.

Applications of Nuclear Energy other than Electricity Generation

Radioactive materials, produced in reactors, are used in diagnostic and therapeutic treatments in medicine, weld inspection (radiography), power sources in remote locations and space applications, and food irradiation.


Copyright 1996-2011.  The Virtual Nuclear Tourist. All rights reserved. Revised: Friday April 01, 2011